We had a wonderful Thanksgiving at Big Bear! This definitely deserves five stars, but do be aware of a few things before you book.
I'll start with the good stuff: soft comfy beds, heater keeps the place toasty, awesome hot tub, convenient kitchen with plenty of dishes, pans, etc., pleasant (but not overdone) mountain decor, great dining table for family meals, big coffee table in living room large enough for puzzles, etc., games and puzzles provided, staff always quick to respond, nice sitting areas in front AND back yards, big backyard with horseshoes, badminton, spa, and gas firepit. The cabin is VERY well organized with just the right things, so that guests can intuitively find what they need. LOVE it!
But, be aware of the following before you book. At the time of our stay, the property was listed as being a two minute walk to Metcalf Bay...more like 15 for a fast walker. (I even emailed about this in advance and the rep assured me that it was 2 minutes. It's not. We'd hoped our kids could easily walk to the lake loaded down with fishing poles and tackle boxes.) The house seemed clean until you open the fridge, look under sinks, etc. Not awful, but not freshly cleaned. I couldn't do it myself, because there wasn't any cleaner. Staff couldn't drop it off, so we had to drive to the office around the lake to get it. Be sure to bring your own cooking oil, spices, etc; at least there wasn't a bunch of expired stuff. Know this going in, and you will have a wonderful stay!